The Winners and Losers of Facebook’s News Feed Changes in 2018

Welcome to the Facebook Marketing Strategy series in which we share the best practices for how to use Facebook for business!  This is part 12 of the series.  

It’s only January, and publishers are already scrambling to reassess their social strategies for 2018 due to Facebook News Feed changes.

The new Facebook algorithm will favor content from friends and family over content from publishers or businesses, pushing publishers to work even harder to get their content seen on the platform.

While this news may seem apocalyptic for media outlets — 45% of U.S. adults get their news from Facebook — the Facebook algorithm update isn’t the end of the world.

Yes, it could be bad in the short term. Publishers will likely see engagement drop if they don’t make moves to adjust to this change. But in the long run, the Facebook News Feed updates will actually be good for the publishing industry as a whole.

Why? Because it will weed out the “losers.” It will cut out those who don’t have what it takes to succeed on Facebook, and it will make more room for those who can adapt and innovate. Small publishers who’ve long been pushed to the side by big-name brands could also stand to benefit from this change, as it may level the playing field a bit.

As Ned Berke wrote for MediaShift, “The planned changes will have less of an impact on the strategies of small publishers, and significant payoff awaits those embracing the fundamentals of engagement.”

The question is: What exactly separates the losers from the winners in this shakeup, and how can you make sure you’re on the winning side?

Let’s take a look.

Winners of the Facebook News Feed Changes

The winners will be publishers that not only embrace the Facebook News Feed changes but also diversify and innovate their content distribution channels. They’ll effectively evolve their strategies by:

Empowering readers to share

Facebook users have a lot of clouts — that’s why you need to encourage them to share on behalf of your brand and empower them to be your amplification system on Facebook.

Remember the Facebook share button? By planting it on your blog posts and articles, you can make it as easy as possible for readers to share right from your page. Take this post from Outside Magazine. Visitors can read it, enjoy it, and share it — all from the same place.

Creating high-quality content

Share buttons are a necessity. But users won’t share unless they deem your content share-worthy. That means publishers should stick to posting high-quality, original storytelling, and cutting the clickbait and “fake” news.

This shouldn’t be too surprising. Facebook has been discouraging clickbait since 2014, and Mark Zuckerberg has been on a mission to battle fake news since the 2016 Presidential Election. He also just announced that users will be asked to rank publishers by how much they trust them. And publishers with low scores may see a decline in their Facebook reach.

“There’s too much sensationalism, misinformation, and polarization in the world today,” Zuckerberg wrote. “Social media enables people to spread information faster than ever before, and if we don’t specifically tackle these problems, then we end up amplifying them. That’s why it’s important that News Feed promotes high-quality news that helps build a sense of common ground.”

Engaging their audiences

Winning publishers won’t phone this one in. Many might be used to posting on Facebook, walking away, and hoping that they receive some engagement in a few hours. But this strategy won’t cut it anymore.

To succeed after the Facebook algorithm update, publishers will have to work hard to cultivate their audiences on Facebook. Facebook Ads Coach Monica Louie recommended publishers to focus on quality over quantity by tweaking the types of content they share on their pages. She emphasized sharing fewer articles and images while focusing more on timely content and posts that encourage thoughtful answers in the comments. For example, you can ask thought-provoking questions and do Facebook Lives that focus on newsworthy information or updates that your audience cares about.

If publishers have any chance of generating engagement and traffic directly from their Pages, it’s going to come from shares and interactions — not just scheduling some posts and calling it a day.

This post from WordStream founder Larry Kim is a great example of this strategy. Kim shared an article about the Facebook algorithm update, and someone commented in response. Not only did Kim reply — illustrating this tactic — but he had some wise words about the effect of the algorithm:

Harnessing the power of influencer marketing

Influencers are the real winners here. They’re now more valuable to publishers than ever because they’re the perfect middleman between media outlets and users — in fact, they’re a little bit of both.

By partnering with influencers, publishers can get their content shared on Facebook by “real” users who are more trusted by the algorithm — and by audiences. Publishers interested in exploring this strategy can take notes of a recent webinar co-hosted by Mention and GoToWebinar. In the webinar, Joei Chan, Content Marketing Manager at Mention and Daniel Waas, Director of Marketing for GoToWebinar, shared several strategies on how to work with influencers to boost credibility, expand reach, and engage a wider audience.

Losers of the Facebook News Feed Changes

The losers will be publishers who don’t adapt to Facebook’s new rules, fail to regularly monitor their ad spend, or use cheap tactics to try and beat the system, including:

Simply spending more for Facebook ads without a clear strategy

Facebook ads have been a saving grace for publishers since the algorithm started to hurt their organic reach. Netta Kivilis, VP of Marketing at Keywee, pointed to some interesting trends. As a platform that helps publishers and brands to distribute and optimize their content, Keywee found that more publishers are paying to promote their content on Facebook and the average ad spend on Facebook continues to increase since 2016.

Despite the fact that sponsored posts are still an important tactic for targeting specific audiences and promoting products, it can’t be the end-all-be-all tactic that drives your Facebook strategy.

Netta recommended that publishers should not simply spend more on Facebook — instead, they should invest in Facebook for strategic initiatives such as audience development, digital subscriber acquisition, and affiliate marketing to boost ROI. Meanwhile, publishers should continue to leverage insights to keep Facebook campaigns efficient and effective.

Allen Finn, Senior Content Marketing Specialist at WordStream, also emphasized the importance of closely monitoring Facebook ad spend to avoid wasting any ad spend. He recommended using a tool such as Facebook Ads Grader to assess the activity and optimize the performance of your Facebook campaign.

Buying low-quality traffic

To make up for the referrals they lose from Facebook, publishers might end up buying traffic, as ad fraud consultant Augustine Fou told Digiday. But a lot of those resellers will only provide low-quality traffic. As a result, publishers will lose money and credibility with advertisers.

“Facebook at least has real human users, which can’t be said of many traffic sellers,” said Jonathan Mendez, a board member of the ad tech firm Yieldbot. “If publishers turn to traffic sellers as a shortcut to replace their declining referrals from Facebook, then they’ll likely end up with a high amount of fraud that drives down their CPMs [cost per impression].”

Focusing only on Facebook

Yes, Facebook is important. But it is not the end-all-be-all of social traffic. Just consider this data from content optimization and analytics platform It clearly shows that referral traffic from Facebook is declining while traffic from Google is rising for its customers.

Referrer Dashboard

Even then, as CTO Andrew Montalenti reported, the overall decline of Facebook is just a few percentage points when you consider all traffic categories, as most publications rely on other sources like search and content aggregators.

That’s why — in the wake of the Facebook algorithm update — you must continue to build out strategies for other referral channels like Google, Flipboard, and dark social.

Dark social, for instance, is a term for when readers copy and paste content links onto their social platforms instead of using share buttons. It’s often a private form of sharing, as it usually happens on the one-to-one or one-to-few channels like email, instant message, or text message. And it can’t easily be tracked since it’s done manually.

At ShareThis, however, we recently analyzed 113 million shares across open and dark social channels to better understand how users share in private. Most notably, we saw a +6% monthly increase in dark social share volume in our publisher network from July 2017 to January 2018. This indicates that a growing number of readers are sharing under the radar.

To stay on top of these shares, publishers need to start offering social media buttons for private channels like text, email, and WhatsApp. This way they can track these dark shares, better understand audience behaviors, and optimize their strategies accordingly.

The Future of the Facebook News Feed Changes

A year from now, when people are selling “I survived the Facebook News Feed Changes of 2018″ T-shirts, you want to be there to collect yours. And you can be. You just have to be smart about how you approach your Facebook strategy in 2018.

Think about it: Facebook probably wants to keep its seat as the biggest social news source. But Zuckerberg wants to make sure people are seeing real, high-quality news stories that are worthy of being shared. Prove that you can provide those stories, and you may make it through just fine.

Make it easy for readers to share your content with the Facebook share button!

About ShareThis

ShareThis has unlocked the power of global digital behavior by synthesizing social share, interest, and intent data since 2007. Powered by consumer behavior on over three million global domains, ShareThis observes real-time actions from real people on real digital destinations.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Get the latest news, tips, and updates


Related Content